Skip Navigation.

The Michaels, Mark & Me

Michael Ignatieff and Michael Coren both hold the same views of our native Indians. The Michaels believe that we should feel responsible for the deaths of the two little native girls at the Yellow Quill reserve in Saskatchewan last January, because we wicked white men introduced the fire water to the poor but noble savages.

Which as most of you readers know, I believe is total horseshit.

In Liberal party leader Michael Ignatieff’s much touted and barely read book True Patriot Love, he opines thusly:

To imagine it as a citizen is to imagine it as a resident of Yellow Quill reservation in Saskatchewan would have had to imagine it, this Canada where two half-naked children died in a snow-covered field in the sub-Arctic darkness because their father tried to take the sick little girls to his parents and never made it, and all you can hope is that death was as mercilessly quick as the cold can make it. What does a resident of Yellow Quill imagine, what do we Canadians imagine our country to be, the morning we learn that children have perished in this way? It is surely more than just a tragic story of one family. It is a story about us.

No, Iggy. It is NOT a story about us. It is a story about a corrupt way of life that breeds substance abuse through a lack of self-reliance, and it is the story about two little children that had no reason to believe they were in any danger at the inept hands of their drunken lout of a father. This is not a story about me, and it is most certainly not a story about you, you arrogant Harvard professor/Canadian of convenience. How do I know this is NOT a story about me? Because from the time I understood the difference between “reservation” and “real world”, I have chosen the latter and railed against the former as being a hotbed of lethargic iniquity. Not a damn bit of good can come to any child of the rez system, so long as touchy-feely do-gooders like Ignatieff and his ilk continue to feed the depravity out of some kind of racist white guilt.

I’m not as eloquent as Mark Steyn, who probably rarely-if-ever uses the term “horseshit”. Yet we seem to be pretty much simpatico on Ignatieff’s hypocrisy.

As to the idea that it’s “a story about us,” no, it’s a story about him: the vandalism he does to the memory of Kaydance and Santana Pauchay, the tasteless opportunism of cashing in on their fate by conscripting a grimly particular episode to the cheap generalities of societal guilt, the horrible glimpse inside the husk of a man once genuinely engaged by Iraq and Bosnia and reduced by ambition to peddling what he knows to be bilge.

To be sure, one could argue that it is “about us” in the sense that Christopher Pauchay wouldn’t be taking his daughters for 50-below midnight strolls in diapers had the white man not unloaded the boat half a millennium ago. Or, alternatively, it’s “about us” in the sense that the lavish government “compassion” and neo-segregationism of the last half-century have inflicted far more damage on Canada’s Aboriginal population than the bead-sellers, mythical smallpox bearers, Victorian imperialists and Christian missionaries could have accomplished in their wildest dreams. I naturally incline to the latter view, which is no doubt “racist.” But isn’t the real racism Ignatieff’s? In seeking, by his weaselly language and revolting argument, to burden all of us with Pauchay’s actions, the Liberal leader is being the quintessential New Racist: he and I are sophisticated human beings who are accountable for our actions, but Christopher Pauchay is excused. To Ignatieff, Pauchay is not fully human, but something closer to a lame animal whom one cannot reasonably hold responsible for his moral choices. If I had to be on the receiving end of whitey’s condescension, I think I’d rather be a “noble savage” than an incorrigible one.

So what has this to do with talk show host Michael Coren? Some of you may remember my appearance on his show back in march, when the subject of Christopher Pauchay’s sentencing circle came up.

Michael was pulling the whole moral relativism that surrounds the alcoholism of the native population, and decrying that us honkeys had a hand in the deaths of Kaydance and Santana. While I can’t exactly remember what I was doing in January 2008, I am fairly certain I was not out in Yellow Quill, either forcing booze down Pauchay’s throat or dragging his nearly-naked daughters out into -50 temperatures. And I will not be tarred with the brush of guilt on account of my white skin and green eyes.

Were you? Was Coren or Ignatieff? Of course not. The deaths of Kaydance and Santana mean nothing to them, or really to the rest of us beyond another tragic tale in the news, yet they must be seen to be making the appropriate mouth noises concerning the natives. The drunk, slatternly and morally corrupt natives whiling away lost lives in government funded (but not enforced, never enforced) concentration camps.

If Christopher Pauchay had been a typical Canadian in Brampton or Fredrickton who had committed this grievous act of negligence, he wouldn’t be pitied and my disgust would be shared by others. I wouldn’t be pooh-pooed for pointing out that he is a corrupt man in a corrupt system, yet should still be prosecuted to the full extent of the law. No, because he is one of the red men, we must coddle him and flagellate ourselves for ever having been born in Canada, descendants of wicked Europeans who raped and pillaged their way across Pauchay’s virgin lands.

To this, I cry horseshit. I didn’t kill those babies. Neither did Michael Ignatieff, Michael Coren or Mark Steyn. And I will not do penance for a crime of someone else’s commission.

10 Comments - Join in the conversation below »

  1. Damn. You’re good, and right, when you get mad RG.

    Comment by Jim R — May 11, 2009 @ 1:48 am

  2. Beautifully said, and very, very true.

    Comment by Barbara — May 11, 2009 @ 5:41 am

  3. Your obviously very uneducated, not to mention very biased in your views about the history of social problems that exist in Canada for First Nations people.

    Comment by Chris — May 11, 2009 @ 10:51 am

  4. Oh brother. Dear Chris, cut the crap. There are many, many, many people on the face of this planet who have endured far, far, far worse oppression though out history who have not followed the same path as Mr. Pauchay and his enablers.

    Study the history of the Jews for the past millennium, for example. Or how about the history of slavery in widely dispersed parts of the globe? What about the many slave owning societies of the west coast of North America (The much exalted Chief Seattle, for example, was a slave owner. Bet you didn’t know that.) and the fact that the Cherokee Indians owned Black slaves. Take a look at who captured and sold African slaves to Colonial American plantation owners? It was the Arabs, that’s who.

    Ask yourself why Cortez found such willing allies among the Aztec’s tribute tribes in Mexico, or what was happening between the Huron and Iroquois before the French showed up. Why are there so many customs and words in the various North American Indian tribes and languages, pre-dating Columbus, that relate to warfare and scalping?

    Study the purely indigenous development of the Songhai Empire in West Africa in the 14th to 16th century or the Mali Empire before that. Or how about the Mongol Empire or the Mughals in India or any of the numerous dynasties in China. Conquest and empire building are hardly unique to Western civilization, so quit apologizing for history.

    The only thing you accomplish with this whining is grievance mongering fixated on wrongs done in the past which cannot be undone (and are hardly comparable to real oppression and abuse, anyway), rather than energizing them and equipping them to participate in the modern world.

    Comment by Louise — May 11, 2009 @ 4:23 pm

  5. Not quite as uneducated and bias as you eh, Chris. Pretty easy to call somebody names without actually giving any proof or even an argument dumb ass.

    Comment by Dave in Guelph — May 11, 2009 @ 10:28 pm

  6. Chris,

    Give us your reasons as to WHY you think that Wendy is being somehow cruelly unjust to our native population? Given the billions of OUR tax dollars that are given to a group of people who continue to live in poverty with serious addition problems, only one word comes to mind.

    Audit.

    I think its high time that we had some accountability for all that money and where its really going don’t you, Chris?

    Bill Gibbons

    Comment by Bill Gibbons — May 12, 2009 @ 3:25 pm

  7. I’m glad you posted that fantastic engagement you had with Michael on his show, and I totally agree with you on your point of view on this issue.

    I watched the Coren Show last night and was left wondering if he had read your blog prior to the show, he did say something about your blog that I didn’t quite catch, and he seemed apprehensive about engaging in another one on one standoff with you again.

    It was great to see you on the Coren show again, I really hope he keeps you coming back.

    Comment by Rural and Right — May 12, 2009 @ 3:30 pm

  8. To those of us who live and work in Indian country this was just another tragedy in a long line of tragedies. It’s not the first nor will it be the last. It’s not the fault of residential schools, which by the way were nowhere near as bad as they have been portrayed, nor the fault of the white man in general. It is the fault of a man who took no responsibility for his own life or the lives of his family. After the sentencing he still didn’t get it, all he could say was “how will jail help me?” Sorry Chris, it’s not all about you. It’s about your little girls and what you did to them.
    The residential schools were not evil, nor did they kill those two little girls.
    The people at Indian affairs are not evil nor did they kill those two little girls.
    The PM and other government figure may well be evil but in this case they did not kill those two little girls.
    The person who sold Chris the booze is not evil and he didn’t kill them either.
    Christopher Pauchay killed Kaydance and Santana Pauchay. His lack of responsibility, and his substance abuse killed them. Just as lack of responsibility and substance abuse will continue to kill Indians until they stand up and take responsibility and no longer drink or get high.
    Now in closing I would like to tell all of you that I like this blog and I respect Wendy but most of you know nothing about the Indians. Many Indians are hard working, family orientated people who take responsibility and contribute to society. Please do not judge all Indians by the actions of Christopher Pauchay or any other Indian who embarrasses his culture. Don’t forget that your own cultures have produced their share of embarrassments. Judge an man, or woman by their actions and their hearts, not the colour of their skin.

    Comment by Tim — May 13, 2009 @ 11:04 pm

  9. [...] MICHAEL IGNATIEFF and Michael Coren both hold the same views of our native Indians. The Michaels believe that we [...]

    Pingback by Steynian 355 « Free Canuckistan! — May 15, 2009 @ 2:35 pm

  10. [...] http://girlontheright.com/2009/05/10/the-michaels-mark-me/ [...]

    Pingback by Marginalized Action Dinosaur » I will not do penance for a crime of someone else’s commission. — May 19, 2009 @ 6:05 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment